|
|
Post by orangeknight on Jul 29, 2015 15:14:05 GMT -5
The list shows the players who got multiple all-american honors (exclude HM) and some outstanding players who have only one all-american season. In your opinion, what class is the best team considering starting line-up and depth chart.
2004
S - Kehoe, McGinnis, Moriarty
RS - Pavan, Kaczor
OH - Morrison, Pressey
MB - Cmaylo, Meyer, Stalls
L -
2005
S - Spicer, Holloway
RS - Korobkova
OH - Fawcett, Barboza, Larson, Houston, Maricic
MB - Akinradewo, Harmotto, Swarbrick, Paolini
L - Miyashiro
2006
S - Glass, Carico, Anderson, Manns
RS - Engle, Brown
OH - Hodge, Cutura, Hooker (Newcombe)
MB - Enesi (Cooper, Okogbaa)
L -
2007
S - Lloyd, Zimmerman, Hagglund
RS - Faucette, Carlson
OH - Lichtman, Klineman, DeBruler, Henson
MB - Wilson, Gibbemeyer, Benson, Fletemier
L - Mass
2008
S - Bateman, Payton, Barker
RS - Murphy, Bartsch, Bergsma
OH - Danielson, Jupiter, Murrey, Carico, Ward
MB - Delano, Adams, Williams
L - (Maroon)
2009
S - Landwehr
RS - Billings, Webster
OH - Henderson, Werth, Mancuso, Turner, Arslanbekova
MB - Jarmoc, Mann
L - (Klefot)
2010
S - Plum (Kreklow)
RS - Scott, Hamson
OH - McClendon, Wittman, Robinson, Hartong, Wicinski, Henning
MB - Slay, Wopat, Dixon, McLaurin
L - Hagglund, Hahn
2011
S - Hancock
RS - (Lowe, Whitney)
OH - Eckerman, Brenner, Vansant, Nelson (Birks)
MB - (Bell, Grant)
L - (Moster)
2012 (Every all-american so far)
S - Bugg (Bergren, Dagostino)
RS - (Bettendorf, Rivers)
OH - Bricio, Gray (Sklar, Burgess, Walch, Gardner)
MB - Ajanaku (McCage, Sybeldon)
L - (Morey, Nolan)
2013 (Every all-american so far)
S - Carlini
RS - (Nwanebu, Holston)
OH - K. Rolfzen
MB - Ogbogu (Holman, Lutz, P. Tapp)
L -
2014 (Every all-american so far)
S -
RS -
OH - (Frantti, Marshall)
MB - (Alhassan)
L -
For class of 2012-2014, they still have chances to make their names in the list. Do you think whoelse will be there?
|
|
|
|
Post by vbcoach06 on Jul 29, 2015 15:17:54 GMT -5
The number of contributors to the USA program makes 2005 kind of a no-brainer to me. Harmotto, Akinradewo and Larson is quite the trio.
|
|
|
|
Post by c4ndlelight on Jul 29, 2015 15:24:51 GMT -5
The number of contributors to the USA program makes 2005 kind of a no-brainer to me. Harmotto, Akinradewo and Larson is quite the trio. Spicer/Fawcett Barboza/Larson Akinradewo/Harmotto Miyashiro 2006 and 2007 might get to 20... maybe.... Nobody else. |
|
|
|
Post by vbnerd on Jul 29, 2015 16:09:46 GMT -5
The number of contributors to the USA program makes 2005 kind of a no-brainer to me. Harmotto, Akinradewo and Larson is quite the trio. Yeah? Do you have a crystal ball to forsee the contributions of the class of 2013 and 2014 or are you prejudiced by age?  |
|
|
|
Post by cardinalvolleyball on Jul 29, 2015 17:43:18 GMT -5
next question should be who would the next best class be since 2005 is hands down the best. I think 2007. 2006 if they had a libero would be there, but nobody on that team can pass so can't have them up there.
|
|
|
|
Post by huskerjen on Jul 29, 2015 18:41:02 GMT -5
next question should be who would the next best class be since 2005 is hands down the best. I think 2007. 2006 if they had a libero would be there, but nobody on that team can pass so can't have them up there. 2007 might be deeper, but I'd take 2011 as 2nd after 2005. That 2011 squad has a nasty mix just based on Micha, Moster, Lowe, Vansant, and Eckerman. Serving, passing, and terminal on pins. |
|
|
|
Post by Cubicle No More ... on Jul 29, 2015 19:03:09 GMT -5
for 2008, you could also slide danielson over to libero, and still leave plenty of firepower (and passing ability) at the OH spots with jupiter, ward, murrey carico
|
|
|
|
Post by ay2013 on Jul 29, 2015 22:45:29 GMT -5
Some solid names missing....2011 is missing Simpson, 2007 is missing Ailes (and anyone with half a brain knows D'errico SHOULD have been an AA from the 07 class, but she was was overshadowed by the big front line at PSU), 06 had Barry, 04 is missing Deesing
2005 would decimate, they have no weaknesses except for maybe the occasional Barboza shank.
As I said in a different thread (which is maybe where the inspiration for this thread came from) 2013 has no passers
Someone mentioned 2007 and 2008 would get to 20, maybe, against 2005....2008 I can see, but 2007 is lacking the firepower, IMO.
The 2009 class is completely forgettable.
After 2005 the next best is some combination of 2006 (they have to find passing), 2010, and 2011
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 29, 2015 23:23:54 GMT -5
Harms is also missing from 09
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 29, 2015 23:36:07 GMT -5
The list shows the players who got multiple all-american honors (exclude HM) and some outstanding players who have only one all-american season. In your opinion, what class is the best team considering starting line-up and depth chart. 2004 S - Kehoe, McGinnis, Moriarty RS - Pavan, Kaczor OH - Morrison, Pressey MB - Cmaylo, Meyer, Stalls L - 2005 S - Spicer, Holloway RS - Korobkova OH - Fawcett, Barboza, Larson, Houston, Maricic MB - Akinradewo, Harmotto, Swarbrick, Paolini L - Miyashiro 2006 S - Glass, Carico, Anderson, Manns RS - Engle, Brown OH - Hodge, Cutura, Hooker (Newcombe) MB - Enesi (Cooper, Okogbaa) L - 2007 S - Lloyd, Zimmerman, Hagglund RS - Faucette, Carlson OH - Lichtman, Klineman, DeBruler, Henson MB - Wilson, Gibbemeyer, Benson, Fletemier L - Mass 2008 S - Bateman, Payton, Barker RS - Murphy, Bartsch, Bergsma OH - Danielson, Jupiter, Murrey, Carico, Ward MB - Delano, Adams, Williams L - (Maroon) 2009 S - Landwehr RS - Billings, Webster OH - Henderson, Werth, Mancuso, Turner, Arslanbekova MB - Jarmoc, Mann L - (Klefot) 2010 S - Plum (Kreklow) RS - Scott, Hamson OH - McClendon, Wittman, Robinson, Hartong, Wicinski, Henning MB - Slay, Wopat, Dixon, McLaurin L - Hagglund, Hahn 2011 S - Hancock RS - (Lowe, Whitney) OH - Eckerman, Brenner, Vansant, Nelson (Birks) MB - (Bell, Grant) L - (Moster) 2012 (Every all-american so far) S - Bugg (Bergren, Dagostino) RS - (Bettendorf, Rivers) OH - Bricio, Gray (Sklar, Burgess, Walch, Gardner) MB - Ajanaku (McCage, Sybeldon) L - (Morey, Nolan) 2013 (Every all-american so far) S - Carlini RS - (Nwanebu, Holston) OH - K. Rolfzen MB - Ogbogu (Holman, Lutz, P. Tapp) L - 2014 (Every all-american so far) S - RS - OH - (Frantti, Marshall) MB - (Alhassan) L - For class of 2012-2014, they still have chances to make their names in the list. Do you think whoelse will be there? I have no idea how you put together the names with the years, but it took me no more than a few seconds to see that there were many inaccuracies. Since the majority of responders agree that 2005 prevails in the survey, it is informative to post the list of the AVCA first team AAs: 2005 AVCA DIVISION I ALL-AMERICA FIRST-TEAMSM Player Institution Pos. Yr. Ht. Hometown Jane Collymore @ University of Florida OH Sr. 6-0 Englewood, Colorado Melissa Elmer ^$ University of Nebraska MB Sr. 6-2 Fort Wayne, Indiana Kim Glass !& University of Arizona OH Sr. 6-4 Lancaster, Pennsylvania Christina Houghtelling University of Nebraska RS/Opp Jr. 6-2 Cambridge, Nebraska Lindsey Hunter # University of Missouri S Sr. 5-10 Papillion, Nebraska Laura Jones # Texas A&M University OH Sr. 6-2 Arlington, Texas Sarah Pavan ^ University of Nebraska RS/Opp So. 6-5 Kitchener, Ontario, Canada Cassie Perret Santa Clara University RS/Opp Sr. 6-1 Menlo Park, California Kristin Richards Stanford University OH Jr. 6-0 Orem, Utah Courtney Thompson ^ University of Washington S Jr. 5-7 Kent, Washington Sanja Tomasevic $ University of Washington OH Sr. 6-1 Uzice, Serbia & Montenegro Sam Tortorello ^$ Penn State University S Sr. 5-11 |
|
|
|
Post by austex2010 on Jul 29, 2015 23:39:59 GMT -5
The list shows the players who got multiple all-american honors (exclude HM) and some outstanding players who have only one all-american season. In your opinion, what class is the best team considering starting line-up and depth chart. 2004 S - Kehoe, McGinnis, Moriarty RS - Pavan, Kaczor OH - Morrison, Pressey MB - Cmaylo, Meyer, Stalls L - 2005 S - Spicer, Holloway RS - Korobkova OH - Fawcett, Barboza, Larson, Houston, Maricic MB - Akinradewo, Harmotto, Swarbrick, Paolini L - Miyashiro 2006 S - Glass, Carico, Anderson, Manns RS - Engle, Brown OH - Hodge, Cutura, Hooker (Newcombe) MB - Enesi (Cooper, Okogbaa) L - 2007 S - Lloyd, Zimmerman, Hagglund RS - Faucette, Carlson OH - Lichtman, Klineman, DeBruler, Henson MB - Wilson, Gibbemeyer, Benson, Fletemier L - Mass 2008 S - Bateman, Payton, Barker RS - Murphy, Bartsch, Bergsma OH - Danielson, Jupiter, Murrey, Carico, Ward MB - Delano, Adams, Williams L - (Maroon) 2009 S - Landwehr RS - Billings, Webster OH - Henderson, Werth, Mancuso, Turner, Arslanbekova MB - Jarmoc, Mann L - (Klefot) 2010 S - Plum (Kreklow) RS - Scott, Hamson OH - McClendon, Wittman, Robinson, Hartong, Wicinski, Henning MB - Slay, Wopat, Dixon, McLaurin L - Hagglund, Hahn 2011 S - Hancock RS - (Lowe, Whitney) OH - Eckerman, Brenner, Vansant, Nelson (Birks) MB - (Bell, Grant) L - (Moster) 2012 (Every all-american so far) S - Bugg (Bergren, Dagostino) RS - (Bettendorf, Rivers) OH - Bricio, Gray (Sklar, Burgess, Walch, Gardner) MB - Ajanaku (McCage, Sybeldon) L - (Morey, Nolan) 2013 (Every all-american so far) S - Carlini RS - (Nwanebu, Holston) OH - K. Rolfzen MB - Ogbogu (Holman, Lutz, P. Tapp) L - 2014 (Every all-american so far) S - RS - OH - (Frantti, Marshall) MB - (Alhassan) L - For class of 2012-2014, they still have chances to make their names in the list. Do you think whoelse will be there? I have no idea how you put together the names with the years, but it took me no more than a few seconds to see that there were many inaccuracies. Since the majority of responders agree that 2005 prevails in the survey, it is informative to post the list of the AVCA first team AAs: 2005 AVCA DIVISION I ALL-AMERICA FIRST-TEAMSM Player Institution Pos. Yr. Ht. Hometown Jane Collymore @ University of Florida OH Sr. 6-0 Englewood, Colorado Melissa Elmer ^$ University of Nebraska MB Sr. 6-2 Fort Wayne, Indiana Kim Glass !& University of Arizona OH Sr. 6-4 Lancaster, Pennsylvania Christina Houghtelling University of Nebraska RS/Opp Jr. 6-2 Cambridge, Nebraska Lindsey Hunter # University of Missouri S Sr. 5-10 Papillion, Nebraska Laura Jones # Texas A&M University OH Sr. 6-2 Arlington, Texas Sarah Pavan ^ University of Nebraska RS/Opp So. 6-5 Kitchener, Ontario, Canada Cassie Perret Santa Clara University RS/Opp Sr. 6-1 Menlo Park, California Kristin Richards Stanford University OH Jr. 6-0 Orem, Utah Courtney Thompson ^ University of Washington S Jr. 5-7 Kent, Washington Sanja Tomasevic $ University of Washington OH Sr. 6-1 Uzice, Serbia & Montenegro Sam Tortorello ^$ Penn State University S Sr. 5-11 They are grouped based on their respective recruiting class. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 29, 2015 23:41:36 GMT -5
The list shows the players who got multiple all-american honors (exclude HM) and some outstanding players who have only one all-american season. In your opinion, what class is the best team considering starting line-up and depth chart. 2004 S - Kehoe, McGinnis, Moriarty RS - Pavan, Kaczor OH - Morrison, Pressey MB - Cmaylo, Meyer, Stalls L - 2005 S - Spicer, Holloway RS - Korobkova OH - Fawcett, Barboza, Larson, Houston, Maricic MB - Akinradewo, Harmotto, Swarbrick, Paolini L - Miyashiro 2006 S - Glass, Carico, Anderson, Manns RS - Engle, Brown OH - Hodge, Cutura, Hooker (Newcombe) MB - Enesi (Cooper, Okogbaa) L - 2007 S - Lloyd, Zimmerman, Hagglund RS - Faucette, Carlson OH - Lichtman, Klineman, DeBruler, Henson MB - Wilson, Gibbemeyer, Benson, Fletemier L - Mass 2008 S - Bateman, Payton, Barker RS - Murphy, Bartsch, Bergsma OH - Danielson, Jupiter, Murrey, Carico, Ward MB - Delano, Adams, Williams L - (Maroon) 2009 S - Landwehr RS - Billings, Webster OH - Henderson, Werth, Mancuso, Turner, Arslanbekova MB - Jarmoc, Mann L - (Klefot) 2010 S - Plum (Kreklow) RS - Scott, Hamson OH - McClendon, Wittman, Robinson, Hartong, Wicinski, Henning MB - Slay, Wopat, Dixon, McLaurin L - Hagglund, Hahn 2011 S - Hancock RS - (Lowe, Whitney) OH - Eckerman, Brenner, Vansant, Nelson (Birks) MB - (Bell, Grant) L - (Moster) 2012 (Every all-american so far) S - Bugg (Bergren, Dagostino) RS - (Bettendorf, Rivers) OH - Bricio, Gray (Sklar, Burgess, Walch, Gardner) MB - Ajanaku (McCage, Sybeldon) L - (Morey, Nolan) 2013 (Every all-american so far) S - Carlini RS - (Nwanebu, Holston) OH - K. Rolfzen MB - Ogbogu (Holman, Lutz, P. Tapp) L - 2014 (Every all-american so far) S - RS - OH - (Frantti, Marshall) MB - (Alhassan) L - For class of 2012-2014, they still have chances to make their names in the list. Do you think whoelse will be there? I have no idea how you put together the names with the years, but it took me no more than a few seconds to see that there were many inaccuracies. Since the majority of responders agree that 2005 prevails in the survey, it is informative to post the list of the AVCA first team AAs: 2005 AVCA DIVISION I ALL-AMERICA FIRST-TEAMSM Player Institution Pos. Yr. Ht. Hometown Jane Collymore @ University of Florida OH Sr. 6-0 Englewood, Colorado Melissa Elmer ^$ University of Nebraska MB Sr. 6-2 Fort Wayne, Indiana Kim Glass !& University of Arizona OH Sr. 6-4 Lancaster, Pennsylvania Christina Houghtelling University of Nebraska RS/Opp Jr. 6-2 Cambridge, Nebraska Lindsey Hunter # University of Missouri S Sr. 5-10 Papillion, Nebraska Laura Jones # Texas A&M University OH Sr. 6-2 Arlington, Texas Sarah Pavan ^ University of Nebraska RS/Opp So. 6-5 Kitchener, Ontario, Canada Cassie Perret Santa Clara University RS/Opp Sr. 6-1 Menlo Park, California Kristin Richards Stanford University OH Jr. 6-0 Orem, Utah Courtney Thompson ^ University of Washington S Jr. 5-7 Kent, Washington Sanja Tomasevic $ University of Washington OH Sr. 6-1 Uzice, Serbia & Montenegro Sam Tortorello ^$ Penn State University S Sr. 5-11 We are talking about high school graduating classes. Most agree that the 05 class with fawcett, larson, barboza, akinradewo, harmotto, miyashiro, spicer, etc, would be the most successful class. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 29, 2015 23:47:02 GMT -5
Ah, thanks for the clarification. (This is my first venture onto VT for several months, and I apologize if I missed something apparent to others, and I retract my criticism.)
|
|
|
|
Post by huskerjen on Jul 30, 2015 0:14:28 GMT -5
2005 was an embarrassment of riches. Their two setters would be Spicer and Holloway? That's disgusting. This should be a discussion about which class was best excluding 2005. It's even generous to say other classes could take 20 pts. off them per set. Probably more in the 14-18 range.
|
|
|
|
Post by Cubicle No More ... on Jul 30, 2015 3:02:13 GMT -5
i feel like this should be closer than it is, and that 2005 wouldn't necessarily just run away with this. 2007, 2008 and 2010 would match up quite nicely.
|
|
